Question 1: So is it really ALL about style?
Let's compare apples to apples (i.e. Sedans), the '08 C170 vs. the '07 C1 (European).
In other words let's leave the ST out of this particular discussion because as of now there is no '08 U.S. performance version.
Granted, the C1 is better looking (subjective) and has a higher quality interior. But, it is more expensive (if it were imported here), heavier, and by most reviews I've read, doesn't handle as well.
Question 2:
Are you willing to pay for a "better looking" car that is more expensive, heavier, and probably doesn't handle as well?
Question 3:
Given the above photos, are the cars really "that" different? Please note that the C1 has a more aggressive wheel/tire package.
This thread is not flame-bait, or tongue in cheek. There are no RIGHT or WRONG answers, only opinions, but it presents serious questions and I hope it gets serious and thoughtful answers.
.
Let's compare apples to apples (i.e. Sedans), the '08 C170 vs. the '07 C1 (European).
In other words let's leave the ST out of this particular discussion because as of now there is no '08 U.S. performance version.
Granted, the C1 is better looking (subjective) and has a higher quality interior. But, it is more expensive (if it were imported here), heavier, and by most reviews I've read, doesn't handle as well.

Question 2:
Are you willing to pay for a "better looking" car that is more expensive, heavier, and probably doesn't handle as well?
Question 3:
Given the above photos, are the cars really "that" different? Please note that the C1 has a more aggressive wheel/tire package.
This thread is not flame-bait, or tongue in cheek. There are no RIGHT or WRONG answers, only opinions, but it presents serious questions and I hope it gets serious and thoughtful answers.
.